New York led by a score of 3-0 in the top of the eighth inning when Judge come up to bat. He hit what appeared to be a towering home run to left field, though the third base umpire ruled the ball foul. A review was ordered, but the call ultimately stood. Reporters asked Judge about the call during the postgame interview.

Aaron Judge and the New York Yankees were angry over the home run that wasn't. Judge drove a changeup from Tampa Bay's Eric Orze deep down the left-field line, high above the foul pole at Steinbrenner Field.

The New York Yankees saw manager Aaron Boone get ejected for the first time this season on Sunday, April 20. After an Aaron Judge strikeout, Boone was mad about the foul-ruled non-home run Judge had hit earlier in the at-bat.