The Toy-Box Killer kidnapped Cynthia pretending to be an undercover cop... and then kept her hostage at his residence for days. Luckily for her, she was able to escape--but not without a fight.

Lucille Johnson, 78, was strangled and beaten to death in her Salt Lake City home in February 1991 The murder has been unsolved for the last 23 years Last year it was reopened and investigators ...